| "Endless Summer" Dallas Lake, IN | 3 | 8 | Analysis |
| "Little Blue" Lake Cottage | 3 | 8 | Analysis |
| 1-bedroom RV, in a quiet spot for couples getaway | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| 10 Minutes to Shipshewana & 1 hour to Notre Dame | 1 | 2 | Analysis |
| 2 bdrm/1bth house/boat dock | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| A 'Peace' on Helmuth Pond | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Adams Lake GEM - Setter Sundown Cottage-Best Views | 3 | 8 | Analysis |
| Authentic Amish Farmhouse near all attractions! | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Basement Apartment *conveniently near Shipshewana* | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Beautiful lake setting in Amish Country | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| Bird’s Nest Air BnB | 1 | 3 | Analysis |
| Blue Birds Perch: Stunning Home on Private Hilltop | 4 | 10 | Analysis |
| Charming Dairy Farm Home in Indiana Amish Country | 3 | 7 | Analysis |
| Charming Lakehouse on All-Sports Big Turkey Lake | 4 | 10 | Analysis |
| Charming, Woodside 6 Bed house w/ Hot Tub | 6 | 12 | Analysis |
| Cheerful Cottage Nestled on Beautiful Witmer Lake | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| clear shallow sandy-bottom lake house + game room | 5 | 16 | Analysis |
| Country Getaway | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Countryside Amish Cottage Near Shipshewana w/ 2 BR | 2 | 5 | Analysis |
| Cozy 3 bedroom cottage close to everything. | 3 | 8 | Analysis |
| Cozy Amish Country Cabin on Shipshewana Lake! | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Cozy Home Retreat | 3 | 10 | Analysis |
| Cozy Industrial Farmhouse Walkout Basement | 1 | 5 | Analysis |
| Cozy Lake-Front Cottage on Westler Lake | 2 | 7 | Analysis |
| Cozy lakefront cottage in the ❤️ of Amish country! | 3 | 7 | Analysis |
| Cozy Nest - Lakefront, Dock, Kayaks, Pet Friendly | 3 | 8 | Analysis |
| Cozy ‘Haven of Rest’ Home w/ Amish Country Views! | 2 | 8 | Analysis |
| Daudy’s Farmhouse | 5 | 12 | Analysis |
| Davis Street in Shipshewana | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Emma's Place | 4 | 8 | Analysis |
| Farmhouse on Farver | 4 | 12 | Analysis |
| Gant Lakehouse Resort | 3 | 10 | Analysis |
| Hackenburg Hideaway - Relax & Refresh by the Lake! | 2 | 8 | Analysis |
| Hidden Creek | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Historic Davis/ The Munoz Home 2 | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Honeyville Cottage | 1 | 2 | Analysis |
| Hook, Wine and Sinker | 3 | 8 | Analysis |
| Howe Retreat w/ Fire Pit + Private Boat Dock! | 3 | 8 | Analysis |
| Hummingbird Cottage | 4 | 8 | Analysis |
| Kayaks | Relax by River | 10 Min to Shipshewana | | 2 | 7 | Analysis |
| Lake house on channel with access to 5 lakes | 2 | 7 | Analysis |
| Lakefront cozy cottage | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Lakefront Getaway on Atwood Lake | 2 | 8 | Analysis |
| Lakefront Vacation Rental ~ 10 Mi to Shipshewana! | 3 | 10 | Analysis |
| Lakehouse on beautiful Big Long Lake | 3 | 8 | Analysis |
| Large Lakefront home with deck, large yard + pier. | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Little Red Hen *NEW* in 2024 | 3 | 8 | Analysis |
| Live & Love Life on the Lake at Sunset Cottage! | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Log Cabin | 1 | 6 | Analysis |
| Log Cabin Haus Pumpkinvine Trail, Shipshewana | 3 | 6 | Analysis |