| #1 Dock swim, float, 2 min walk to Indiana beach! | 1 | 3 | Analysis |
| #2 Dock swim, float, 2 min walk to Indiana beach! | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| #3 Docks Kayak Swim! 2 min walk to Indiana beach! | 1 | 5 | Analysis |
| #4 Dock swim, float, 2 min walk to Indiana beach! | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| #5 Dock swim, float, 2 min walk to Indiana beach! | 2 | 5 | Analysis |
| 1 Bedroom + Sleeping Alcove Cottage #5 | 2 | 5 | Analysis |
| 1 Bedroom + Sleeping Alcove Cottage #6 | 2 | 5 | Analysis |
| 1 bedroom + Sleeping Alcove Cottage #8 | 2 | 5 | Analysis |
| 1 Bedroom + Sleeping Alcove Cottage #9 | 2 | 5 | Analysis |
| 2 Bedroom + 2 Sleeping Alcoves Perfect For a Group | 2 | 8 | Analysis |
| 2 Bedroom Cottage on Lake Shafer | 2 | 5 | Analysis |
| 2 bedrooms Cottage #4 Perfect for families! | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| 3 bedroom Game room home 10 min from Indiana Beach | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| 3 Bedroom River Retreat with lake access | 3 | 7 | Analysis |
| 3,800 Sq Ft., Rustic Luxury Estate On Lake Freeman | 5 | 15 | Analysis |
| Adorable House on Lake Shafer! | 3 | 10 | Analysis |
| Amazing Lakefront House with all the Amenities! | 5 | 10 | Analysis |
| Beautiful Lake Freeman Home w/Great View/Boat Dock | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Charming Riverfront Retreat in Monticello! | 3 | 7 | Analysis |
| Cheerful Lakeside Studio | 1 | 3 | Analysis |
| Cozy cottage, close to town | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| Cozy Lake Shafer 2 Bedroom Suite | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| CozyCabin | 3 | 7 | Analysis |
| Deluxe Lakefront Cottage with Private Deck | 2 | 8 | Analysis |
| Dly Wkly Mthly Rates Avail 01/01 to 04/30/25 2bd | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Lake Freeman Home: Boat Lift, Close to Sandbar! | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Lake Shafer 1 Bedroom Suite | 1 | 3 | Analysis |
| Lake Shafer 2 Bedroom Suite | 2 | 5 | Analysis |
| Lake Shafer 3 bedroom 2 bath lakefront house | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Lakefront Cottage w/ Deck Near Indiana Beach! | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Lakehouse on Big Monon | 2 | 5 | Analysis |
| Lakeside Bliss: Wonderful Lake Views & Access | 2 | 8 | Analysis |
| Luse Lodge | 3 | 10 | Analysis |
| Mellow Yellow on Shafer | 4 | 12 | Analysis |
| Modern lake front house w/ HOT TUB for 10 people! | 4 | 10 | Analysis |
| Panoramic view on Lake Freeman! | 3 | 9 | Analysis |
| Quaint Lakefront Cottage with Private Deck | 2 | 5 | Analysis |
| Riverbend Cottage | 1 | 3 | Analysis |
| Riverfront Brookston Retreat w/ Deck & River Tubes | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Riverfront home with access to Lake Freeman. | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Riverside Retreat | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Rustic farmhouse with a cabin vibe | 7 | 16 | Analysis |
| Sleeps 15: Hot tub, fireplace, lakefront! | 5 | 15 | Analysis |
| Stay & Play at Indiana Beach! | 3 | 9 | Analysis |
| Studio unit with kitchenette #11 | 1 | 2 | Analysis |
| Studio unit with kitchenette #12 | 1 | 2 | Analysis |
| Studio unit with kitchenette #2 | 1 | 2 | Analysis |
| Studio unit with kitchenette #3 | 1 | 2 | Analysis |
| The Hidden Gem | 4 | 9 | Analysis |
| The Sandbar Cottage on Lake Freeman | 4 | 15 | Analysis |