| 1 bedroom loft on the Historic Centerville Square | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| Access to all that Rathbun Lake has to offer. | 5 | 8 | Analysis |
| Adventure Awaits! | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Antler Acres, 2 bedroom 1 bath, sleeps 6 | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Antler Acres, 3 Bedroom, 2 Bath | 3 | 7 | Analysis |
| Barndominium minutes to Rathbun Lake! | 5 | 13 | Analysis |
| Bass - sleeps up to four | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| Bear Cub - Sleeps up to Four | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| Bed and Breakfast Guest Room | 1 | 2 | Analysis |
| Big Bear - Sleeps up to 8 - Handicap Accessible | 2 | 8 | Analysis |
| Black Lab - Dog-Friendly - Sleeps up to Four | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| Bluegill - Sleeps up to Two Adults | 1 | 2 | Analysis |
| Bobcat's Den - Dog Friendly - Sleeps up to 8 | 3 | 8 | Analysis |
| Coal Miner's Cottage | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Delightful Hobbit House in the woods | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Eagle's Nest - Sleeps up to 10 | 2 | 10 | Analysis |
| Elk - Sleeps up to 6 | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Full Campus Rental - Weddings/Family Reunions | 1 | 16 | Analysis |
| Harv's Uptown Retreat | 2 | 10 | Analysis |
| Honey Haven | 6 | Analysis | |
| House on Lake with in ground pool & camper hookup | 3 | 15 | Analysis |
| Journey Cabin | 1 | 6 | Analysis |
| Journey Cabin II | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Lake House with a private trail to the beach! | 4 | 10 | Analysis |
| Luxury Suite located near Rathbun Lake | 3 | 10 | Analysis |
| Majestic Hunting Lodge | 6 | 14 | Analysis |
| Majestic Hunting Lodge | 3 | 7 | Analysis |
| Mid Century Modern-close to city park and pool. | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Moose - Sleeps up to 6 | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Outdoorsman Haven! Hot showers and cozy! | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Pheasant - Dog-Friendly - Sleeps up to Four | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| Private Townhome Apartment in Historic Hotel | 2 | 7 | Analysis |
| Quail Run - Dog-Friendly - Sleeps up to Four | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| Rathbun Lake Get Away Rental at Antler Acres | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Rathbun Lake House | 3 | 8 | Analysis |
| Rathbun Lake Rustic Retreat | 6 | 16 | Analysis |
| Sunny Days Valley View Villa 1 | 3 | 10 | Analysis |
| Sunny Days Valley View Villa 3 | 4 | 14 | Analysis |
| Sweetwoods | 3 | 10 | Analysis |
| Timber Ridge Cabin cozy studio/loft #4 | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| Timber Ridge cozy 3 bedrooms cabin #1 | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Timber Ridge cozy cabin studio/loft #5 | 4 | Analysis | |
| Timber Ridge Log Cabins Moravia 4Bedrooms cabin #2 | 4 | 8 | Analysis |
| TimberRidge cabin cozy studio/loft #3 | 4 | Analysis | |
| Updated home away from home in Centerville | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Vintage Brick Apt On Historic Square | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| Walleye - Sleeps up to Five | 1 | 5 | Analysis |
| Whispering Oaks Getaway Cabin | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Whitetail - Sleeps up to Six | 1 | 6 | Analysis |
| Yellow Lab - Sleeps up to Three Adults | 1 | 3 | Analysis |