| "Sassy Retreat" for that much needed get-a-way | 2 | 10 | Analysis |
| *LAKE FRONT* 3BR Cottage w/kayaks WIFI golf cart | 3 | 7 | Analysis |
| 1920's style Bungalow easy walk downtown | 2 | 5 | Analysis |
| 2 Family Cottages on Orchard Island | 4 | 8 | Analysis |
| 3 Bedroom & King Bed North Indian Lake | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| 3-Bedroom Lakefront Home with Dock, Kayaks, & SUP! | 3 | 8 | Analysis |
| 4-Bedroom Lower Level Only/ Hot Tub/ Kitchenette | 4 | 11 | Analysis |
| A lil R&R at the Lake | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| A Restful Landing | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| A spacious getaway on Orchard Island | 3 | 8 | Analysis |
| Adorable 2BR Lake House Perfect for wknd Getaway. | 2 | 5 | Analysis |
| All Oar Nothing Island Lake House! | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| All-Season Indian Lake Home w/ Covered Deck! | 4 | 9 | Analysis |
| Along the Mohawk Path | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Amazing lakefront retreat for large gatherings! | 5 | 16 | Analysis |
| Anchor Bend Bungalow on Indian Lake + Waterfront | 3 | 8 | Analysis |
| Bamboo Cottage | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Beautiful Indian Lake Getaway!! | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Blackbird on the Mad River Cabin | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Blue Bayou Lake house | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Blue Jacket Cabin at Indian Lake | 4 | 16 | Analysis |
| Campground Tiny Home #42 | 1 | 6 | Analysis |
| Campground Tiny Home #44 | 1 | 6 | Analysis |
| Campground Tiny Home #46 | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Charming 2BR Lake House Perfect for wknd Getaway | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Charming Historic Piatt Cabin - 1 Bedroom | 1 | 2 | Analysis |
| Charming Historic Piatt Cabin - 4 Bedroom | 4 | 8 | Analysis |
| Charming nautical cottage | 2 | Analysis | |
| Cheerful 3-Bedroom Cottage with Indoor Fireplace | 3 | 8 | Analysis |
| Chippewa Cottage at Indian Lake | 3 | 10 | Analysis |
| Clean Lake House, Free WiFi! The Hodge Podge Lodge | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Close to downtown, Rustic, Cozy, Toasty | 1 | 2 | Analysis |
| Cottage by the Swim-Up Pool Bar | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Country Escapes. Located 3 miles from Honda ELP | 1 | 3 | Analysis |
| Cozy 2 Bedroom Apartment in West Liberty | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Cozy apartment near the lake, with historic charm | 1 | 3 | Analysis |
| Cozy Cabin on the Lake | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Cozy Cottage | 2 | 5 | Analysis |
| Cozy Cottage at Indian Lake, Ohio | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| Cozy Cottage in Russels Point with Fire Pit | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Cozy cottage on Turkey Foot Island, Indian Lake | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Cozy Lake House w/ Boat Dock & Canal | 4 | 10 | Analysis |
| Cozy White Cottage Canal Indian Lake Private Dock | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Croft House | 4 | 16 | Analysis |
| Delightful tiny house located on 110 wooded acres | 1 | 2 | Analysis |
| Desperados 2 Bedroom Nest | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Downtown Russells Point Cottage Near Indian Lake! | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Dunaway Lodge | 2 | 16 | Analysis |
| Duplex in Lakeview (A Side) | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Duplex in Lakeview (B- side) | 3 | 6 | Analysis |