| A slice of heaven in the woods | 1 | 2 | Analysis |
| Albany House B&B | 4 | 8 | Analysis |
| Authentic Swiss Chalet | 6 | 14 | Analysis |
| Bdrm w/ a view: Room to roam+ rest | 1 | 2 | Analysis |
| Charming Chalet Family Suite | 1 | 6 | Analysis |
| Cheerful 3-bedroom chalet in Little Switzerland | 3 | 9 | Analysis |
| Close to historic downtown | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Corner Cottage | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Cottage in the Valley, 50 acres | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| Cozy 1BR/1B Garden guest Unit | 1 | 2 | Analysis |
| Cozy Bungalow | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Cozy Cabin on Decatur Lake | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| Cozy Home near Historic Square | 1 | 2 | Analysis |
| Cozy House with Lots of Charm | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| Cozy Upper Flat in New Glarus | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| Cute, century-old house in Monroe | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| das Baumhaus on Monroe’s Historic Square-2 bedroom | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Dottie's Place with a valley view | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Firefly Log Home | 4 | 12 | Analysis |
| Fresh & Bright Apartment Getaway in New Glarus | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| Fully equipped 2BR*Hidden gem nestled in the woods | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Historic Country Farmhouse for Any Season! | 5 | 8 | Analysis |
| Historic Lustron Home | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Holy Cow! New Glarus Guest Haus | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Home away from home, close to historic square | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| J & S Comfort Home | 2 | 5 | Analysis |
| KC HOUSE Beautiful ranch in the country! | 5 | 10 | Analysis |
| Kennedy's Guest House | 1 | 5 | Analysis |
| Large Great Room - 12 Ft Ceiling - Cool Antiques | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Little Swiss "Quacks Nest" With a View | 3 | 8 | Analysis |
| Little Vintage Charmer | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Loft 3 - On The Historic Monroe Square | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| Lookout Loft on Historic Square | 1 | 3 | Analysis |
| Lovely 2 Bedroom Rental with Deck | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| MJ's Penthouse ( A piece of paradise in Monroe) | 1 | 6 | Analysis |
| Nationally Registered Historic Home | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| New Glarus, 3 queen beds and pull out couch | 2 | 8 | Analysis |
| Nördlich Chalet - Trail-side, 1 Bdrm in New Glarus | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| On the Square House | 3 | 7 | Analysis |
| Peaceful Retreat with Modern Amenities~ EV Charger | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Plenty of Space in the Heart of Downtown | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Rolling Hills Retreat w/ Pickleball Court (1 Bdr) | 1 | 2 | Analysis |
| Rolling Hills Retreat w/ Pickleball Court (3 Bdr) | 3 | 6 | Analysis |
| Rollings Hills Retreat w/ Pickleball Court (2 Bdr) | 2 | 4 | Analysis |
| Sawmill Creek Farm-Close to New Glarus, 5 bedrooms | 5 | 10 | Analysis |
| Spacious Villa*Beautiful Views*Country Setting | 4 | 8 | Analysis |
| Stay in the Heart of Downtown New Glarus! | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Süden Chalet - Trail-side, 1 Bdrm in New Glarus | 1 | 4 | Analysis |
| Sugar River Airbnb | 2 | 6 | Analysis |
| Sugar River Hideaway | 3 | 6 | Analysis |